Skip to content

SONATA in A major, Op. 2 No. 2

The second sonata (opus 2 no 2) in the sunny key of A major is wonderfully fresh music. You can hear birds sing as if you’re out in the forest. In contrast to the dramatic first sonata, this sonata is lyrical and tender, whereas the third sonata is brillant and humorous. Together, the three opus 2 sonatas are incredibly diverse. Unfortunately, the second sonata is seldom played, probably because of its huge technical difficulty. This difficulty and the radical tendencies make it clear that Beethoven intended to outdo his predecessors early on: this sonata is already well beyond Haydn and Mozart. In fact, Beethoven almost shows the way forward to Schubert.

The exposition of the first movement, allegro vivace, is reminiscent of Haydn symphonies, although Beethoven’s masterly and modern-sounding modulations, emotional violence and excitement are new. One of the first -though unplayable- examples of fingering by Beethoven is found here. The development is full of huge, dramatic outbursts and very difficult to play.

The second movement, largo appassionato, is extraordinary. A hymn tune marked tenuto, accompanied by what sounds like a pizzicato bass, which creates a wonderful sonority. This kind of fuller sonority is new on the keyboard and, in fact, new in the history of music. Beethoven changes proportions and dynamics so that the music grows in volume to sonorities that almost make you think of Brahms, who was a great admirer of Beethoven. Brahms’ F major cello sonata is ‘inspired’ by this sonata.

The third movement, allegretto, is charming and graceful. Schubert must have loved it: his late A major sonata was ‘inspired’ by this scherzo. The trio is in the tonic key, but in the minor. There is some hidden agitation there.

The last movement, grazioso, is a rondo and one of Beethoven’s most elegant creations. Beethoven shows that he is not only a ‘heavy-weight’ composer, but also a very complex composer. He has many different faces. Also, the grazioso belies some people’s claim that Beethoven was not a great melodist. According to András Schiff, Beethoven could write the most wonderful melodies if he wanted to, but he simply didn’t always want that. This movement is very vocal, a hommage to the opera. Beethoven deploys a huge operatic downward leap, together with a motif borrowed from the first movement – the rising A arpeggio.

Back To Top